A firing can be unfair, abrupt, or handled poorly and still be legal. It only becomes “wrongful” when the reason for it breaks the law, such as when the termination violates a statute, goes against public policy, or breaches an agreement that limits the employer’s discretion.
Here are the main legal reasons a firing can be considered wrongful:
Federal law prohibits firing someone because of their race, sex, age, disability, or other protected characteristics. California as well as other states expand protections further, sometimes covering smaller employers or additional categories like marital status or gender identity. Below are examples where the stated reason for the termination didn’t hold up because the real reason was tied to bias.
An employee reported that coworkers had made racial slurs toward him on the shop floor. Instead of investigating, the company fired him the following week. Several, less experienced employees of a different race were kept. There was no record of performance issues or misconduct in his file.
After telling HR she was pregnant, a manager with strong annual reviews was suddenly removed from a high-profile account. Two weeks later, she was terminated. Her company cited a “restructuring,” but she was the only person affected.
A 62-year-old sales rep was let go during a team reorganization. Internal messages described the change as “bringing in fresh energy.” Three younger employees with lower numbers stayed on. There was no evidence of misconduct or any attempt to document underperformance.
A retail employee with Down syndrome had worked at the company for fifteen years. When a new manager took over, he asked for minor schedule changes related to medical needs. Instead of adjusting the schedule, the company terminated him. A jury awarded $125 million in damages. (see EEOC v. Walmart Stores East, LP (2021))
An employee brought his same-sex partner to the company holiday party. Two days later, he was pulled into a meeting and fired. There were no complaints about his conduct or performance on record, and no explanation was given beyond “not a good fit.”
Employees who report harassment, discrimination, wage violations, and other unlawful conduct are protected by law. There are also laws that protect those who participate in investigations or exercise rights under wage, leave, or labor laws. Employers don’t usually admit that a firing was linked to a complaint, but it becomes clear that the termination was retaliation if it happens right around the same time as the complaint and the stated reason for the firing doesn’t line up with the employee’s record or recent performance.
An employee reported that her supervisor was making repeated sexual comments. There was no investigation. She was written up for “team conflict” the following week and terminated shortly after. Her personnel file included recent positive reviews and no record of prior discipline.
A line cook raised concerns to his manager about not receiving overtime pay for weekend shifts. The next day, he was sent home early. By the end of the week, he was terminated for “poor attitude.”
A woman filed a sex discrimination case with the EEOC. Shortly after, her fiancé—who worked for the same company—was terminated. The Supreme Court ruled the firing was unlawful retaliation because of his connection to her complaint (Thompson v. North American Stainless).
A factory worker told his supervisor that the company was shorting employees on hours worked. He was fired the next day and his company argued that no formal complaint had been made. The Supreme Court disagreed and held that oral complaints are protected under the Fair Labor Standards Act (see Kasten v. Saint-Gobain).
Employees who do the right thing when faced with unlawful conduct are protected by law. Workers have that protection when they refuse to carry out an illegal order, report misconduct, or meet a civic duty like serving on a jury. When a termination follows, it can violate public policy and expose the employer to liability.
A finance employee was told to adjust company records to hide losses, she refused, and was terminated two weeks later. Her company called the decision “restructuring,” yet no one else lost their job.
A warehouse worker contacted OSHA after repeated safety complaints went unanswered, and within days he was written up for “disrupting operations” and then fired. A write-up appeared for the first time in an otherwise clean record.
A customer service representative served on a jury for four days, and when she returned, her schedule was cut to zero hours. Management cited “availability issues,” even though her jury notice had been submitted weeks before.
Several factory employees reported that their employer was hiring undocumented workers and paying them below minimum wage, and all were terminated the following week. A California court found the firing violated public policy because it punished them for exposing unlawful practices (Jie v. Liang Tai).
Employees have a right to take protected time off for medical, family, or military reasons without losing their job. Firing someone for using protected leave violates federal law and, in some states, additional laws that provide even broader coverage.
An employee took several weeks of approved leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act to care for a parent recovering from surgery, and when she returned, her manager cited “attendance issues” and terminated her. Her record before the leave showed no performance problems, and her absences were documented and approved.
A National Guard member gave notice of mandatory training scheduled for the following month, and a week before it began, his employer terminated him. Management said the role needed to be filled immediately, even though coworkers had already been covering his workload.
A project manager went on maternity leave and was told midway through that her position had been eliminated. Leadership described it as a restructuring, yet no other positions were cut and her projects were reassigned to another employee.
Written agreements are not the only way employers can limit their right to fire at will. Policies, handbooks, and even verbal assurances can create expectations that the employer is required to follow. When those promises are ignored, a termination can breach an implied contract or violate the employer’s own rules.
An operations manager was fired without any prior warnings, even though the employee handbook required progressive discipline before termination. Other employees in similar situations had received multiple written warnings, and the failure to follow that policy supported a finding that the firing breached an implied agreement.
A high-performing account executive was fired five days before she was about to get an annual bonus. Her results placed her among the top earners in her department, and no performance issues were documented. The timing made clear the termination was intended to avoid paying compensation already earned.
A regional project manager accepted a position after being told the role would last at least a year, he relocated for the job, and within three months was terminated without cause. Testimony from other managers confirmed that the employer routinely made similar assurances to recruit candidates, creating enforceable expectations of job security.
Some state laws protect employees from being fired for lawful conduct that happens outside of work, so it may be a violation of the law when an employer terminates someone for engaging in legal, off-duty activity.
An office administrator attended a peaceful protest on a weekend and shared a photo from the event online, and the following Monday her supervisor terminated her. States including California, New York, and Colorado prohibit employers from firing someone for lawful political activity outside of work hours.
A delivery driver tested positive for THC after using cannabis legally at home, and the employer terminated him even though his performance had never been questioned. California’s updated law, effective in 2024, now protects employees from being fired or disciplined for off-duty cannabis use when it doesn’t affect their work.
A resignation can still count as a termination when conditions become unbearable and management refuses to intervene.
A warehouse employee endured daily racial harassment from coworkers, HR ignored his complaints, and after months he resigned under stress. It was later determined that the resignation amounted to a firing because management’s refusal to act left no reasonable option to stay.
Some firings feel unfair but don’t violate any law. At-will employment allows an employer to terminate someone for nearly any reason, as long as it isn’t connected to discrimination, retaliation, or a protected right.
A marketing analyst was fired because the new department head said she didn’t “fit in.” Her work performance met expectations, and no policy or protected category was involved. Personal tension or poor chemistry with management, standing alone, does not make a firing wrongful.
A longtime office administrator lost her job during a departmental reorganization. Several roles were cut across the company, and no link was found between the layoffs and any protected characteristic. A business decision to reduce staff can be unfair in outcome but lawful under at-will rules.
An employee was dismissed without explanation and his employer gave no cause and offered no written statement. Unless the termination relates to a protected activity or trait, an employer in an at-will state is allowed to end employment without giving a reason.
A firing can feel personal, abrupt, or undeserved, but the key question is whether it broke the law. When a termination violates discrimination, retaliation, or public policy protections, employees have options to act.
If you feel you may have been wrongfully terminated, reach out to The Law Offices of Jeremy Pasternak for a free consultation by calling (415) 693-0300 or sending a message through our contact form.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Viewing this content does not create an attorney-client relationship with The Law Offices of Jeremy Pasternak. Employment law varies by state and situation, and legal outcomes depend on specific facts and applicable laws. While we make every effort to ensure accuracy, laws change, and unintended errors or omissions may occur. For advice on your particular circumstances, consult an attorney.